Pick a cooling technology and see what one year of operation takes in Phoenix, Ashburn and Raleigh-Durham: electricity, water, carbon and utility cost. The numbers come from an hourly model run on 2023 NOAA station weather.
Share of the 1 MW the equipment is sized for.
The hybrid plant runs dry at or below this outdoor temperature.
More cycles mean less tower blowdown and less makeup water.
The large numbers are for the selected technology. The bars under each one compare all three.
Monthly totals for the three technologies. The three panels share one scale.
Hours of 2023 at each outdoor temperature, colored by the plant that carries the load under the selected technology.
Each line is the hybrid plant at every switch temperature, from all wet at the right to all dry at the left. Move the switch slider to travel along it.
Each hour of 2023 is solved on its own for a constant heat load. The dry plant is an air-cooled chiller. The wet plant is a water-cooled chiller with a counterflow cooling tower, a variable-speed tower fan and a condenser-water pump. Both chillers follow the code-minimum performance curves of ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2022, as published with EnergyPlus.
Water is the tower makeup: evaporation, drift and blowdown. Evaporation comes from an air-side balance with saturated leaving air, so it rises in hot, dry weather. CO₂ uses the eGRID2023 subregion rates. Cost uses 2023 state-average commercial electricity prices and local water and sewer rates, with sewer billed on blowdown.
The electricity is that of the heat-rejection plant only (chiller, tower fan and condenser pump), so it cannot be read as PUE. Electricity prices carry no demand charge. The hybrid plant owns two full plants, and capital cost is outside the scope.
Sources: NOAA Local Climatological Data, 2023 station files; EPA eGRID2023 summary data, Revision 2; EIA average electricity prices, 2023; EnergyPlus chiller curves and tower defaults; Braun, Klein and Mitchell (1989), cooling tower model.